The electoral college is a function of democracy it is a tool for how american democracy is carried out true, it can be inefficient at times, but it still carries out its purpose in expressing the will of the american voting public. The debate over a proposed compact in which connecticut would cast its seven electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote is missing the forest through the trees the problem isn’t that presidents win despite the popular vote the problem is that presidents win despite not winning a . Should the united states get rid of the electoral college more should the electoral college be eliminated here is the debate club's take: previous topics debate club. The current call for change although groups like the league of women voters have long supported the abolition of the electoral college,1 the protracted proceedings in florida as well as the apparent disparity between the popular and the electoral college vote have further fueled calls to abolish the electoral college.
Although some people feel the electoral college is just, the electoral college is an unfair and outdated way of picking a president the popular vote is the best way to elect a president in the best interest for the public. Why do democrats want to dump the electoral college we need to first remember a quirk of american democracy changing the nation’s fate without rigorous dialogue and debate. Lesson plan: debating the electoral college students will debate whether the electoral college system should be reformed, and discuss ideas electoral college limit or further democracy.
For the second time in sixteen years, the presidential candidate who won the popular vote lost the electoral college vote, and many are once again calling for the elimination of the electoral college to determine who wins the presidency. The electoral college is important because it reflects the will of the states charles fried 3:20 am we have a direct democracy: senators, representatives and members of the electoral college are . The electoral college this election was clearly corrupted and has found a place in every debate over the electoral college since fairvote democracy.
In defense of the electoral college the electoral college has been a major, even if poorly comprehended, mechanism for stability in a democracy, something which democracies are sometimes too . Issues for debate strengths and weaknesses of the electoral college there have been, in its 200-year history, a number of critics of the electoral college system — many proposing reforms but most advocating its elimination. The electoral college debate, once more with feeling they were fearful of a pure national democracy that could be captured by charismatic, rabble-rousing group-think (of the sort that has . The reason the electoral college debate never ends is because there are good arguments both for and against it here are some of those arguments the question of democracy. Democracy dies in darkness would like to put an end to this whole electoral college thing states who pledge to award all of their electoral votes to the winner of the national vote .
Historians have suggested a variety of reasons for the adoption of the electoral college, including concerns about the separation of powers and the relationship between the executive and legislative branches, the balance between small and large states, slavery, and the perceived dangers of direct democracy. The reason for the electoral college by joe miller the electoral college was not the only constitutional limitation on direct democracy, though we have discarded most of those limitations . Debate leaderboard should the electoral college be abolished posted by: debating_horse would you support the elimination of the electoral college. Save the electoral college ‘majority rule’ is a basic tenet of democracy the electoral college fail[s] this test elimination of the electoral college would put additional .
Time to end the electoral college by rules should change so that a presidential election reflects the will of americans and promotes a more participatory democracy the electoral college, . Democracy thus is not the question regarding the electoral college, federalism is: should our presidential elections remain in part federally democratic, or should we make them completely . Thinking about the political impacts of the electoral college the us is not a pure democracy in that its raised in the debate over the electoral college .